Close Menu
The Punished BacklogThe Punished Backlog
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    The Punished BacklogThe Punished Backlog
    • Home
      • Content Directory
    • News
      • Humor
      • Punished Chat
      • Punished Notes
      • Fantasy Gaming
      • Friday Fortissimo
    • Guides
    • Features
      • Lists
      • Opinion
      • Interviews
      • Best of the Year
      • Punished Favorites
      • Punished Hall of Fame
    • Previews
    • Reviews
      • Breaking Reviews
      • Backlog Reviews
    • Podcasts
      • The Punished Podcast
      • Weekend at Dave’s
    • About Us
      • Our Story
      • Meet The Team
      • Our Review Scale
      • Contact Us
    • Write for Us
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram TikTok YouTube
    The Punished BacklogThe Punished Backlog
    Home»Reviews»Breaking Reviews»Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: “Alligator Man”
    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Breaking Reviews Reviews

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: “Alligator Man”

    David SilbertBy David SilbertMarch 2, 20181 Comment7 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn Email

    Robbin’ Season Starts Off Strong

    Donald Glover is no stranger to success. Initially a sketch comic during his studies at New York University, Glover quickly gained traction with his writing work on the show 30 Rock. In 2009, Glover took a full-time acting gig with his portrayal of Troy Barnes on NBC’s cult classic Community. At the same time, he diversified his portfolio by releasing music under the Wu-Tang generated pseudonym Childish Gambino.

    Fast forward years later, and Donald Glover hasn’t skipped a beat. He’s both an Emmy and Grammy award winner, putting him halfway towards the coveted EGOT at the age of 34. He’s set to star as Lando Calrissian in the upcoming Han Solo origin film, Solo: A Star Wars Story, immortalizing himself alongside the biggest film franchise of all time. He’s also lending his voice as Simba in Disney’s 2019 remake of The Lion King, putting his theatrical singing chops to the test. Stand-up, writer, actor, director, singer, performer… Glover does it all.

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    Atlanta is perhaps the greatest culmination to date of Glover’s lifelong work. An FX series created by, written by, directed by, and starring Glover that began serialization in September 2016, Atlanta released its premier season to rave reviews. As “Earn” Marks, Glover plays a reserved Princeton dropout who has returned home to Atlanta in order to get his life sorted out. Alongside his irritable cousin-turned-rapper Alfred “Paper Boi” Miles and spacey wingman Darius, Earn spent the better part of Atlanta’s first season in pursuit of stability and security for him, his girlfriend Vanessa, and his daughter.

    After a 2017 hiatus, Atlanta is finally back for Season 2. If the even raver reviews aren’t enough to whet your appetite for this sophomore season, I’ll be sharing my thoughts on each of the season’s episodes on Fridays after the show airs. First up? The Atlanta S2 premiere, “Alligator Man.”

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    Steady Mobbin’, Steady Robbin’

    In what has become the norm for Atlanta, “Alligator Man” begins with the unexpected. Curtis and Droop, a pair of new characters, make plans to score some weed by way of ordering a “number 17” at Mrs. Winner’s, a nearby fast food drive-thru. Initially suggested over the casual sipping of Powerade (“Hey, n***a. A cup.”) and playing of FIFA on Xbox (“Boy, you trash.”), the scheme made between the two friends comes across as harmless, if not a little stupid.

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    The scene at the drive-thru reinforces this fact. After Droop orders a laundry list of food items ending with a number 17, the man at the speaker rings up the order as totalling $60.85, much to the relief of Curtis and his pal (weed doesn’t come cheap, after all). As the pair rolls away from the camera towards the pick-up window, this scene seems oddly ordinary. As we would soon find out, something is up.

    As the young adults (possibly even teens?) pull up to the 2nd window, a camera change switches perspectives to the worker manning the register. As he opens the window to hand over the food (and hemp), he is met by Droop in a panda mask and Curtis pointing a gun in his face.

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    Curtis fires off a few shots and heads into the restaurant. After finding the cashier’s stash of the drug, he makes for the door again. To his surprise (and to ours), the cashier fires back with a fully-automatic assault rifle. After an intense gunfight causes Curtis to make a duck-and-run, he and Droop pull away in their car, the cashier shooting after them.

    Again, with Atlanta, we expect the unexpected. Rather than the getaway vehicle, er…. getting away like at the end of a typical B-movie action scene, the cashier’s shots land. The car stops abruptly, and a bloodied young woman hops out of the car before shrieking about something we can’t see. It’s unclear whether she’s traumatised, or hurt, or something completely different. It’s also unclear how she ended up in the car in the first place (I double-checked, and the car the boys arrived in is the same as the one they pulled away in).

    Regardless of the unanswered questions that this opening scene leaves us, one thing is certain: it’s “robbin’ season” in Atlanta, and that means a much darker, much more brutal Atlanta the show for Season 2.

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    Tension Among Friends

    Following its unorthodox opening, “Alligator Man” continues by catching up on our central three characters. Earn, having been kicked out of his temporary storage pod home, makes his way back to Paper Boi’s place to see if his cousin will let him stay for the time being. There, he finds that his two friends are in the middle of an argument, complete with the silent treatment, although neither friend will explain why.

    In fact, “Alligator Man” doesn’t do much in the way of explaining at all. Earn is on parole for having possessed illegal drugs with intent to sell (a half a joint), and yet like the fight between Alfred and Darius, we don’t know why.

    Still, the tension between the two friends and hazy predicament surrounding the group made for some hilarious moments throughout the episode. From Al and Darius both coldly replying “I don’t want to talk about it” when pressed by Earn, to Al sharply barking “N***a, take me off speaker” after an innocent attempt to bring the two together, “Alligator Man” brought some classic Atlanta humor that felt right at home during the season premiere.

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    Alligator Man

    Punctuating this episode of Atlanta is the appearance of Earn’s uncle (and presumably Paper Boi’s father), Willy. Played by the ever-phenomenal Katt Williams, Uncle Willy brings both a lot of questions and a lot of side-splitting moments. First, there’s Earn’s amical relationship with Willy’s girlfriend Yvonne, whom Willy later describes to the police by saying, “No. She don’t live here. I’m fucking the bitch.” Then, there’s the dramatic buildup to the moment where Earn explains to the cops that he’s Willy’s nephew. And, of course, there’s the alligator in the closet.

    The appearance of the feisty Alligator Man and his confrontation with Earn immediately sets up an interesting dilemma: is Earn still a welcome part of the Paper Boi crew? As Al’s fame and reputation continue to mount, will the cousins’ bond as rapper and manager strengthen, or weaken?

    Though Willy brings a lively energy to “Alligator Man,” he and Yvonne’s introduction were perhaps a bit too much all to juggle in the Season 2 premiere, especially following the dramatic scene with Droop and Curtis. Who are all these people? How do they advance the plot? Still, a lot of character development early on is hardly a bad thing for a show as ambitious and as far-reaching as Atlanta. We’ll have to see what lies in store in future episodes.

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 1 Review: "Alligator Man"
    Photo Credit: FX Networks

    Final Thoughts

    While “Alligator Man” struggles in finding a satisfying balance between its old characters and new ones, the Season 2 premiere of Atlanta offered enough entertaining moments to keep me satisfied throughout. Golden nuggets I didn’t mention above include Earn talking his way out of mistaking Al’s girlfriend, Tara, with a side-chick named “Regina,” Darius’ absurd telling of the legend of “Florida Man,” and Uncle Willy comically booking it down the street like the end of an old Western.

    At the end of the day, it’s just good to have Atlanta back again. And while “robbin’ season” looks set to bring more drama and tragedy to the show than ever before, it also looks to offer the same ridiculous, off-the-wall humor that made Season 1 such a big hit. Buckle up for the ride.

    Score: 8.7/10

    Atlanta Atlanta Season 2 Donald Glover FX FX Networks Paper Boi Robbin' Season
    Subscribe
    Notify of
    guest

    guest

    1 Comment
    Oldest
    Newest Most Voted
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    HKK
    HKK
    1 year ago

    It took tremendous amount of time to realize the reason behind the feud between Al and Darius, so kindly hear my thought. In the very beginning of the scene at the Al’s crib, a girl called Tara lies on the sofa while there are some negative energy between him and Darius. Highlighting the importance of her, when Earn and Darius get back to Al’s crib, Tara is NOT there and they seem to be back on the amicable terms (“you wanna smoke some?”), meaning that their fight can be related to her for a reason we would never know. Besides… Read more »

    0
    Reply
    Previous ArticleSurvivorology – Survivor: Ghost Island Episodes 1-2 Recap
    Next Article Celeste Review
    David Silbert
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Tumblr
    • LinkedIn

    David is the creator and lead editor of The Punished Backlog. He has a problem finishing games he starts. Just beat: Star Wars Jedi: Survivor. Working on: Tears of the Kingdom, Elden Ring, Neon White, Persona 5: Royal. Can't wait for: Hollow Knight: Silksong. Follow David on Twitter at @David_Silbert to keep up to date with all things The Punished Backlog.

    Related Posts

    9.7

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 6 Review: “Teddy Perkins”

    May 7, 201810 Mins Read
    Read More
    9.0

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 5 Review: “Barbershop”

    April 10, 20189 Mins Read
    Read More
    9.6

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 4 Review: “Helen”

    March 31, 201811 Mins Read
    Read More
    8.4

    Atlanta Season 2 Episode 2 Review: “Sportin’ Waves”

    March 10, 20188 Mins Read
    Read More
    Latest Posts

    The 16 Best Cozy Video Games (and Why the Genre Works)

    November 29, 2023

    The Punished Podcast – Episode 3: The Backlog

    November 21, 2023

    Friday Fortissimo – 11/17: “Beware the Forest’s Mushrooms” (Super Mario RPG)

    November 17, 2023

    We Need More Low-Stakes Adaptations Like Pokémon Concierge

    November 15, 2023
    Like Us on Facebook
    The Punished Backlog
    Follow Us on Twitter
    Follow @PunishedBacklog
    Follow Us on Instagram

    punishedbacklog

    Just a small group of friends who love to write about #videogames, big and small. Want us to cover a game? Reach out and let us know! 🎮 👇

    The Punished Backlog
    Introducing our newest project, The Punished Podca Introducing our newest project, The Punished Podcast! 

In episode one, TPB editors Sam Martinelli, David Silbert @davidmsilbert, and Amanda Tien @amandajotien discuss the difference between remakes and remasters. We also share our favorite memories of the Nintendo DS.

Check it out over on punishedbacklog.com. (Link in bio)

#podcast #videogames #gamingpodcast
    "SEASON: A Letter to the Future is an unforgettabl "SEASON: A Letter to the Future is an unforgettable story about the power of memories—how joyful it can be to make them, and how painful it can be to lose them."

@seasonthegame @scavstudio 

Read our full review: https://punishedbacklog.com/season-a-letter-to-the-future-review/
    For those #summer #saturday vibes when you just rl For those #summer #saturday vibes when you just rly don’t want to go outside and sweat. #indiegames #videogames #nature
    @amandajotien gave #Stray a 7.9/10 overall but a 1 @amandajotien gave #Stray a 7.9/10 overall but a 100/10 for a cat-in-a-bucket simulator. Link in our bio for our newest reviews. #videogames #indiegames #cute #cat
    Follow on Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram TikTok YouTube
    Proud contributor to OpenCritic.com.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    wpDiscuz